Victory Garden
(Now Closed)Ice Cream Parlor$$$$
West Village, New York
The experts at Eater and The Corcoran Group recommend this place
118 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Celena ChanAugust 3, 2015This is my absolute favorite place to get soft serve dessert-- above all froyo places. To me, the tangy goat isn't "goaty" at all, but if you are not a fan, try the caramel! So decadent!
Serious EatsMarch 29, 2013This West village spot offers some of our favorite soft serve ice cream in NYC, made with goat's milk. Ask if they have Turkish ice cream, Dondurma, as well
Village VoiceAugust 15, 2014The salty caramel is a beautiful rendition of cajeta, and the herbal soft serve has all the flavors of herbes de provence, drying in the summer sun. Read more
Dan FetznerJune 28, 2016Got The Queen which was an insane amount of ice cream even for me and I'm a pig. A little on the pricey side and not as good as Big Gay Ice Cream Shoppe but much shorter lines & a nice change of pace
Untapped CitiesJanuary 7, 2016At Victory Garden, you can buy goat milk ice cream, with flavors ranging from Chocolate Cardamom, Orange Blossom Vanilla, Honey Lavender, and Ethiopian Coffee. Read more
All the soft serve here is goat's milk-based. Try the Salted Caramel or Chocolate Mastic for something sweeter, or go for the original Tangy Goat Milk for a lighter flavor.
Corinna PMay 9, 2013If you were wondering whether they do goat petting tours at their upstate farm, the answer is no. But the goat yogurt is delicious. And the tangy goat ice cream too.- Thomas MoAugust 13, 2014Salted caramel and tangy goat milk are great for a first comer. Be sure to come back and try their daily/weekly special flavors such as rosemary.
Halstead PropertyJune 13, 2013You really only get one chance to vote yay or nay on something like tangy goat milk ice cream, luckily our first taste of it was here and now we can't get enough. It's even better paired with honey.
Laura RoosApril 28, 2013The goats milk soft serve is amazing!! Definitely get the original or go for the salted caramel. The orange honey blossom is great too...you just can't go wrong!!
The Corcoran GroupJuly 13, 2012Trust us, you’ll fall head over heels for their goat milk soft serve ice cream – the Tangy Goat Milk is simply perfect, and the Salted Caramel is to die for.
Wilson ZhouAugust 8, 2014Sophia Brittan adorns her Cheap Eats award-winning goat's-milk soft-serve with lightly poached Jersey peaches and a fresh raspberry sauce. Peach Melba Sundae
Children's Museum of the Arts 103 Charlton StNovember 30, 2011CMA Pick: Looking for a sweet treat in the neighborhood? Go here! Goat’s milk based soft serve is divine. They get bonus points for their local ingredients and super friendly, sample giving cashiers.
Sloane TrugmanNovember 18, 2014Heavens! Tangy goat for the win. Get it topped w some rose-quince sauce. Salty chocolate ain't bad either.
Joe GermuskaAugust 2, 2013"Ever wanted to try goat milk soft serve? This is your place. We like it for its crisp, light texture and Eastern Mediterranean flavors… if they're serving Dondurma, get some."
Foursquare InsidersSeptember 11, 2015"Try flavors like Rose Petal and Basil Chip. If anything is going to remind you to wake up and smell the summer, it's got to be frozen basil. No?" - Leandra Medine of Man Repeller Read more
Maya ShanmugamJuly 4, 2015The midsummer night's dream sundae (tangy goat milk) is so good! Love the bay leaf black currant sauce. It can feed ~2-3.
Gilt CitySeptember 21, 2011You can gussy up the distinctive flavors (some with floral essences like lemon poppy and rose petal) with a myriad of seasonal toppings like honeycomb candy, pretzels and maple marshmallows.
Mike NickersonSeptember 29, 2016Absolutely delicious gelato! Made with 100% goat milk. Very unique, seasonal flavors. The s'mores with cookie crumble is divine
The goat products on the left are really nice for housewarming presents. Still, the soft serve here is really the star. I have to resist going basically every day.
Kate FurmanFebruary 1, 2016A unique ice cream spot made only with goat milk. Try the salted caramel with cookie crumble topping.
Stephanie CansianSeptember 1, 2014The salted caramel goat's milk soft serve is out of this world! Pair it with a little Halavah on top for crunch.
Sara 🌈⚔🍾September 6, 2014So delicious. The "tangy goat milk" flavor is amazing and just sweet enough to satisfy a sweet tooth.
NicoleJuly 8, 2012Super delicious, thoughtful ice cream. Yet it misses the point that ice cream should be fun, like when you are a kid. Salted caramel is yum.
Zakk MannellaOctober 2, 2014My favorite place for a quick lunch and dessert. I highly recommend the kale and lentil soup, and the caramel soft serve.
Arnaud RéautéOctober 22, 2015Ice creams are very tasty and always seasonal but there aren't that many choices and the advanced stuff (sundaes, toppings) are too expensive.
Emily WilsonOctober 4, 2015Try anything here. It's all really interesting and good. The salted caramel is a winner for sure.
Kelwadis ButlerFebruary 2, 2012Try combining a the salty/sweet caramel with the bitter chocolate ice cream, either side-by-side or in a swirl. The combination is really good.
Ricky Adhari SwissantoJune 5, 2014…we all scream for ice cream! pure bliss is a mere brainfreeze away. So whether you go classic cone or sundae-style with all the fixin’s, we won’t judge. Unless it’s frozen yogurt.
Hungry TurnipJuly 20, 2016salted caramel soft serve with chocolate chip cookie crumbles, pistachios, and cajeta (goat milk caramel)
Goat milk is safe if you're lactose-intolerant like me; try the salted caramel soft serve with halvah topping!- Nate BeattyOctober 6, 2015Ice cream that's just the right amount of tart (and just the right amount of goat).
- Village VoiceJune 11, 2012Salty caramel, herbal and tangy goat's milk soft serve. It's no wonderwe voted Victory Garden the best ice cream spot in NYC.
Erica ChoiJuly 20, 2013Goat milk (ice cream) is definitely an acquired taste. Try a tasting before buying a cup of it!
David DunhillJanuary 11, 2016Tangy goat milk soft serve with salted fudge. A great dessert at any time.
JeffreyAugust 31, 2014The soft-serve is made from goat’s milk. But it’s also a full-fledged, health-minded kitchen.
Rachel DonleyJuly 7, 2015Dirt sundae was good, but the lavender chocolate sea salt ice cream really shines on it's own
The Mastic ice cream also contains a special ingredient from the mountains of South Eastern Turkey. . . come in and ask us what it is!
Dylan StilinFebruary 15, 2014Great ice cream and possibly some of the best toppings you will find anywhere.
Sammy GoldfienApril 17, 2013Ice cream is good but they have non-sweets too! The market plate is a nice, hearty, healthy salad.
Zayed KhanJuly 18, 2013Impossible to go wrong with salted caramel, but you'd do well to add halva topping to it.- Zayed KhanJuly 18, 2013The tangy goat milk might change the way you think about soft serve and all its possibilities. Drizzle some warm honey over it for absolute perfection.
Incredible simple salads and sandwiches that use local, seasonal ingredients. Also: hibiscus-rose tea.
Christina ChinAugust 16, 2015Salted caramel, yum. Got kids size, don't really taste the difference in goat milk
312 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Victory Garden
31 Carmine St (btwn Bleecker & Bedford St)
New York, NY 10014
United States
New York, NY 10014
United States
Serving fresh Goat Milk Soft Serve Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt. We also have refreshing drinks, iced coffees, and yogurt parfaits. Our Salted Caramel ice cream is addictive!
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- Noon–11:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(212) 206-7273
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Beautifully presented good quality gelato. A little bit of Florence in NY!"
Jason H. - 8.3
"Delicious - tried the strawberry and so good! Bubble tea festival"
Elizabeth Burstein - 8.6
"lil britt special: 50/50 vanilla/peanut butter froyo, lots of kitkat pieces, generous helpings of marshmallow and peanut butter sauces"
Britt
Places people like to go after Victory Garden
- 9.5
"Always an amazing mix of people and entertainment. One of my fav spots to lay in summer."
Barton Smith - 8.8
"Ginger, wasabi, sesame, and taro root ice cream. Yum!"
Casey Gollan - 7.4
"Watching the fountain all lit up at night while enjoying a light breeze, the splashing of water and stranger's conversations is a perfect New York evening."
Hunter
Appears on 566 lists
Created by Serious Eats
41 items • 216 followers
Created by PCholic
18 items • 477 followers
